Shower vs. Tub: What Should You Consider?

There's no universal rule that every bathroom needs a tub, or that every renovation should replace one with a shower. Start with who uses the bathroom.

A shower may make sense when

You value easier entry, more standing room, a larger shower area, or frequent daily showering.

A tub may make sense when

Your household uses baths, has young children, wants a soaking option, or simply prefers having a tub.

Think about accessibility

A high tub wall can become difficult for some users, while a properly designed shower may offer easier entry.

Think about the rest of the house

Removing the only bathtub is different from removing one of several. Consider your household's likely needs rather than a blanket resale rule.

Waterproofing matters either way

The visible tile is not the waterproofing system. Shower and tub-surround construction needs appropriate water management behind the finished surfaces.

Don't design only for appearance

Think about entry, storage, cleaning, grab-bar planning, shower controls, lighting, and ventilation.