When Should You Get a Second Estimate for a Home Repair?

Not every repair requires three contractors standing in your driveway. But some projects are worth comparing.

Consider another estimate when

• The project is large.
• Replacement is being recommended.
• The diagnosis isn't clear.
• The scope differs from what you expected.
• The contractor can't explain the recommendation.
• You have time to compare safely.

Don't delay an active hazard

Shopping estimates shouldn't come before immediate safety. Active electrical hazards, major uncontrolled water, sewage, dangerous structural conditions, and other immediate risks come first.

Compare the diagnosis

Two different totals aren't meaningful if the contractors diagnosed different problems. Ask each one: what do you believe is wrong?

Compare scope

Look for differences in materials, labor, removal, disposal, permits, restoration, warranty, and exclusions.

Ask why recommendations differ

One contractor may propose repair while another proposes replacement. Ask each to explain why. The explanation is often more useful than the price alone.